Ford Mustang Gen 1 in Indianapolis metro area for sale
2 for sale now · 3 previously sold in this exact combination.
Market Snapshot
Median asking (for sale now): $39,450 (n=2) · Median sold (last 24 months): $24,500 (n=3)
Median sold price by quarter — all Ford Mustang Gen 1 (this combination has too few dated sales for its own trend)
Medians of actual prices; call-for-price cars are excluded. Sold figures use dated sales only, each labeled with its sample size.
For sale now (2)
74,530 miles · 3 Speed Automatic · Torch Red
Greenwood, IN
SOURCE: Dealer
$44,000
54% above the typical asking price for a Mustang Convertible
Expand
Seller: Ray Skillman Collector Car Sales
Transmission: 3 Speed Automatic
Condition: Body: Convertible. Mileage shown as 74,530. Transmission: 3 Speed Automatic. Exterior: Torch Red. Interior: Black.
Color: Torch Red
71,443 miles · Automatic
Plainfield, IN
SOURCE: Dealer
$34,900
26% below the typical asking price for a Mustang
Expand
Seller: GR Auto Gallery
Transmission: Automatic
Previously sold (3)
Mileage not stated · Tangerine
Greenwood, IN
SOURCE: Dealer
$44,000
Expand
Seller: Ray Skillman Collector Car Sales
Condition: Body: Coupe. Exterior: Tangerine. Interior: Beige.
Color: Tangerine
Sold Nov 19, 2026
Mileage not stated · Red
Greenwood, IN
SOURCE: Dealer
$24,500
Expand
Seller: Ray Skillman Collector Car Sales
Condition: Exterior: Red. Interior: Black.
Color: Red
Sold Nov 19, 2026
Mileage not stated · Red
Greenwood, IN
SOURCE: Dealer
$23,500
Expand
Seller: Ray Skillman Collector Car Sales
Condition: Body: Fastback. Exterior: Red. Interior: White.
Color: Red
Sold Nov 19, 2026





