Ford Mustang Gen 1 Automatic in Ohio for sale
5 for sale now · 3 previously sold in this exact combination.
Market Snapshot
Median asking (for sale now): $14,900 (n=5) · Median sold (last 24 months): $41,500 (n=3)
Median sold price by quarter — all Ford Mustang Gen 1 (this combination has too few dated sales for its own trend)
Medians of actual prices; call-for-price cars are excluded. Sold figures use dated sales only, each labeled with its sample size.
For sale now (5)
26,560 miles · Automatic · Green
Columbus, OH
SOURCE: Dealer
$25,995
45% below the typical asking price for a Mustang Grande
Expand
Seller: Cruisin Classics
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Mileage shown as 26,560. Transmission: Automatic. Exterior: Green. Interior: Green.
Color: Green
56,830 miles · Automatic · Yellow
Dayton, OH
SOURCE: Dealer
$27,500
42% below the typical asking price for a Mustang
Expand
Seller: Gem City Classic Autos
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Mileage shown as 56,830. Transmission: Automatic. Exterior: Yellow. Interior: Black.
Color: Yellow
119,500 miles · Automatic · Red
West Unity, OH
SOURCE: eBay
$10,500
78% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang
Expand
Seller: 69mstng
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1973; VIN (Vehicle Identification Number): 3F03H165761; Mileage: 119500; Body Type: Convertible; Transmission: Automatic; Number of Cylinders: 8; Make: Ford; Drive Type: RWD; Fuel Type: Gasoline; For Sale By: Private Seller; Model: Mustang; Exterior Color: Red; Vehicle Title: Clean; Engine: 351c. This car is located in West unity ohio. I have a clear title in hand
Color: Red
88,236 miles · Automatic · Blue
Hudson, OH
SOURCE: eBay
$13,500
71% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang
Expand
Seller: jedidnk
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1970; Mileage: 88236; Interior Color: Black; Body Type: Coupe; Number of Seats: 4; Transmission: Automatic; Make: Ford; Fuel Type: Gasoline; For Sale By: Private Seller; Drive Side: Left-Hand Drive; Date of 1st Registration: 20210615; Model: Mustang; Exterior Color: Blue; Car Type: Classic Cars; Number of Doors: 2; Vehicle Title: Clean; Engine: 302 V8. Garage kept since 2002 302 roller rocker 750 holly double pump MSD Ignition system Large radiator Power steering transmission cooler Clean title in hand Freddy Brown AOD shift kit transmission. With B&M shifter 355 gear rear end 3 1/2 “ Cherry bombs exhaust Hooker super comp ceramic headers Not original parts at all Rust in quarters Rust in bottom of doors New driver floor pan Left turn signal does doesn’t lock on NO rust in rails and pans see pics Runs and drives registered and classic insured in OH Brakes need adjustment soft as is listing I have no time for this anymore got it to work on with my old man and since he’s gone now just don’t have the time or energy to finish it
Color: Blue
74,000 miles · Automatic · Gold
Salem, OH
SOURCE: Facebook
$14,900
68% below the typical asking price for a Ford Mustang
Expand
Seller: Marketplace seller
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own Facebook Marketplace listing: Year: 1966; Mileage: 74000; Transmission: Automatic; Exterior Color: Gold.
Color: Gold
Previously sold (3)
73,086 miles · Automatic · Medium Gold
Columbus, OH
SOURCE: Dealer
$72,995
Expand
Seller: Cruisin Classics
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Mileage shown as 73,086. Transmission: Automatic. Exterior: Medium Gold. Interior: Saddle Brown.
Color: Medium Gold
Sold Nov 19, 2026
36,000 miles · Automatic · Red
Cincinnati, OH
SOURCE: eBay
$18,500
Expand
Seller: brianewing274
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Listing details from the car's own eBay listing: Year: 1965; VIN (Vehicle Identification Number): 5F08T60046; Mileage: 36000; Body Type: Convertible; Transmission: Automatic; Number of Cylinders: 6; Make: Ford; Drive Type: RWD; Fuel Type: Gasoline; For Sale By: Private Seller; Model: Mustang; Exterior Color: Red; Vehicle Title: Clean; Engine: 200. Has small transmission pan leak. Manual drum brakes and steering. Runs well not bad for 60 years old
Color: Red
Sold Nov 12, 2026
55,004 miles · Automatic · Blue
Dayton, OH
SOURCE: Dealer
$41,500
Expand
Seller: Gem City Classic Autos
Transmission: Automatic
Condition: Mileage shown as 55,004. Transmission: Automatic. Exterior: BLUE. Interior: Black.
Color: Blue
Sold Nov 8, 2026
More Mustang Gen 1 combinations
Oregon Automatic (3)Orlando metro area (0)Orlando metro area Automatic (0)Pennsylvania (16)Pennsylvania Automatic (8)Pennsylvania Manual (4)Phoenix metro area (5)Phoenix metro area Automatic (2)Raleigh - Durham metro area (9)San Diego metro area (3)San Diego metro area Automatic (2)San Diego metro area Black (2)








