Home / Chrysler / Full Size / Fifth Avenue buyer's guide

Chrysler Fifth Avenue buyer's guide

Chrysler Fifth Avenue -- the model's own buyer's guide: variants, values and what to check.

Years listed: 1987-1987 · Series: Full Size

# Chrysler Fifth Avenue — buyer's guide

Overview and history

The first thing to understand about the Chrysler Fifth Avenue is that the name covers three different cars, built on three different platforms, with almost nothing interchangeable between them. What unites them is not engineering but intent: each one is Chrysler selling traditional American luxury — a V8 or a large V6, a soft ride, deep seats, a padded vinyl roof and as much bright trim as the styling studio could attach — to a buyer who did not want a smaller, harder, European-flavoured car. If that buyer is you, a Fifth Avenue delivers the formula honestly and cheaply. If you buy the wrong generation by accident, you get a car you never wanted, so learn the three shapes before you learn anything else. The name arrives first as an option, not a model. For 1980 and 1981 the Fifth Avenue Edition is the top trim package on the Chrysler New Yorker, flagship of the rear-wheel-drive R-body range — the big, square, unit-body sedans Chrysler launched for 1979. These are full-size cars in the old sense: long bonnet, formal upright roofline, a 318 or 360 cubic inch V8 up front and a live axle behind. When the R-body dies after 1981, Chrysler's big rear-drive flagship idea dies with it, and the name has to find a smaller home.

It finds one in the M-body. From 1982 the Fifth Avenue becomes a model in its own right, built on the platform that began life in 1977 under the Chrysler LeBaron and is shared, in plainer clothes, with the Dodge Diplomat and the Plymouth Gran Fury. The M-body's roots go further back still, to the 1976 Dodge Aspen and Plymouth Volaré: transverse torsion bars at the front, a live axle on leaf springs at the back, a pushrod V8 and a three-speed TorqueFlite automatic. By 1982 that hardware is old-fashioned — but it is also paid for, understood by every mechanic in America, and exactly what the remaining traditional buyers and the fleet market want. The Fifth Avenue is the luxury version: more sound insulation, plusher trim, a distinctive padded roof treatment and, from 1985, a four-barrel carburettor on its standard 318 V8. It sells steadily right through to 1989 — the last rear-wheel-drive Chrysler sedan of its era.

The third car is the break. For 1990 the Fifth Avenue name moves to the front-wheel-drive Y-body, the stretched, formal flagship Chrysler builds alongside the contemporary Imperial. The V8, the propshaft and the live axle are gone; in their place sit a transversely mounted V6 — 3.3 litres at first, 3.8 litres from 1991 — and Chrysler's electronically controlled Ultradrive four-speed automatic. The styling works hard to hide the revolution: the roofline stays formal, the seats stay pillowy, the wood-effect trim stays. Underneath, though, this is a different ownership proposition entirely, with different strengths (space efficiency, traction, a more modern drive) and one very different weakness, the gearbox, which the problem-areas section covers in detail. Production ends after 1993. The cars you will actually meet for sale follow that history. In this site's own current pool for the model, the M-body cars of 1984 to 1987 make up the bulk of what is offered, with a single 1980 R-body car and a single 1991 Y-body car at either end — a fair picture of the wider market, where the M-body is the Fifth Avenue most people mean and most people can still find. This guide covers all three generations, weights its detail towards the M-body, and flags every point where a check applies to one generation only. Read the identity notes in the models section before you travel: a surprising number of Fifth Avenue arguments turn out to be two people describing different generations.

A 1984 M-body Fifth Avenue from the rear three-quarter: this is the shape most buyers mean by the name. Read the padded vinyl roof panel behind the rear door, the full-width segmented tail lamps, the gold Fifth Avenue script on the bootlid and the wire wheel covers.

The models

Three generations, one nameplate, and a crowd of near-relatives you must be able to separate from the real thing. Start with the relatives, because they generate most of the confusion. The M-body Fifth Avenue shares its shell and mechanical package with the Dodge Diplomat and Plymouth Gran Fury, and with the earlier Chrysler LeBaron built on the same platform from 1977 to 1981. The badges, the roof treatment and the interior trim settle identity, and the VIN plate on the driver's side of the dashboard, read through the windscreen, settles it beyond argument — check that the paperwork describes the car in front of you before you discuss money.

The R-body car of 1980–81 is a New Yorker first and a Fifth Avenue second: the name denotes the edition package, with its distinctive roof treatment and upgraded interior, applied to Chrysler's full-size flagship. These are the biggest Fifth Avenues, the only ones offered with the 360 cubic inch V8, and the rarest survivors, because the R-body range as a whole sold modestly and was never loved by collectors.

The M-body car, 1982–89, is the core of the model and the simplest to follow, because Chrysler changed it remarkably little across eight model years. Every M-body Fifth Avenue is a four-door sedan. Every one has the 318 cubic inch (5.2-litre) LA V8 and a three-speed TorqueFlite automatic; there is no manual gearbox, no six-cylinder Fifth Avenue and no two-door, whatever a seller's advert claims — the six-cylinder and two-door M-bodies exist, but they wear LeBaron, Diplomat or Gran Fury badges. The meaningful changes are these. The 1982 and 1983 cars use a two-barrel carburettor. From 1985 the engine gains a four-barrel carburettor and a useful step in output, and the later cars are the ones to favour if performance matters to you at all. Trim evolves in detail — wheel cover designs, badging, interior fabrics — rather than in substance, and the special editions you may meet, such as the Frank Sinatra editions offered in the early 1980s, are Fifth Avenues with a marketing package rather than a different car. Judge them as the underlying car, not as the badge.

The Y-body car, 1990–93, returns the name to flagship duty alongside the Imperial, from which it differs mainly in trim and detail. It is front-wheel drive, V6-powered and four-speed automatic. The 1990 cars carry the 3.3-litre V6; from 1991 the 3.8-litre becomes the standard engine and is the better drive. These cars are roomier inside than the M-body for a similar road footprint, and considerably more complicated in their gearbox and electronics. They are also the generation most often misdescribed in adverts as a continuation of the rear-drive car. It is not: a buyer who wants the traditional car should walk away from a Y-body however good it looks, just as a buyer who wants the modern one should not be talked into an M-body by a seller trading on the shared name.

ModelYearsEngineOutputBuiltCharacter
New Yorker Fifth Avenue Edition (R-body)1980–1981318 or 360 cu in LA V8Modest, emissions-era; the 360 is the strongerEdition package on the R-body flagship; two model years only, the scarcest of the threeThe full-size original: biggest, softest, rarest
Fifth Avenue (M-body), two-barrel1982–1984318 cu in LA V8, 2-barrelAbout 130 hpThe volume years begin; retail and fleet-adjacent demandThe traditional car in its purest, simplest form
Fifth Avenue (M-body), four-barrel1985–1989318 cu in LA V8, 4-barrelAbout 140 hpThe long, steady run to the end of rear-drive productionThe pick of the range: more go, same simplicity
Fifth Avenue (Y-body)1990–19933.3 or 3.8-litre V6About 147–150 hpFinal run, built alongside the ImperialThe modern interpretation: front-drive, V6, electronic gearbox

Two identity checks apply across the range and cost you nothing. First, the roof: the M-body Fifth Avenue's padded vinyl covering is a signature of the model — a car advertised as a Fifth Avenue with a plain painted roof and plain trim deserves a hard look at its badges and paperwork, because it may be a Diplomat or LeBaron dressed up. Second, the engine: an M-body Fifth Avenue with a slant-six or a V6 under the bonnet is not a rare variant, it is a different model or an engine swap. Open the bonnet before you open negotiations.

The front of a 1987 M-body car: the upright chrome grille with its fine vertical bars, the Pentastar bonnet ornament, paired rectangular sealed-beam headlamps and the deep chrome bumper are pure traditional Chrysler. Check the grille surround and bumper chrome closely on any car — brightwork this large is expensive to re-plate and reproduction pieces are not made.

Engines and gearboxes

The LA V8: 318 and 360

Every rear-drive Fifth Avenue runs a member of Chrysler's LA small-block family, one of the most thoroughly understood engines in American motoring. The LA is a pushrod, overhead-valve V8 with a cast-iron block and cast-iron heads, hydraulic tappets, a single camshaft in the block and a two-plane intake manifold under a downdraught carburettor. It is not sophisticated and it is not stressed: in Fifth Avenue tune it makes its power low in the rev range, turns slowly at a cruise and lasts a very long time when its oil is changed. That unstressed character, more than any single component, is why so many of these cars survive.

The standard engine, in the R-body New Yorker Fifth Avenue Edition and in every M-body car, is the 318: 318 cubic inches, 5.2 litres, with a bore and stroke chosen for smoothness rather than output. In two-barrel form, as fitted to the 1982–84 M-body cars and the R-body, it produces around 130 hp and a broad, lazy spread of torque. From 1985 the M-body car uses a four-barrel carburettor — a Rochester Quadrajet, an interesting cross-marque borrowing that surprises buyers who expect a Carter or a Thermoquad — and output rises to around 140 hp with noticeably better throttle response and overtaking ability.

The 360, offered in the R-body car, is the same architecture with more displacement and, in period tune, a modest output advantage bought with heavier fuel consumption.

Mechanically, the LA asks for little and forgives much, but it has known habits you should understand before the problem-areas section. The factory timing drive uses a camshaft sprocket whose teeth are moulded in nylon over a metal hub, a refinement for quietness that becomes a liability with age: the nylon hardens, cracks and sheds teeth, the chain jumps, and an engine that ran yesterday will not start today — or, worse, jumps one tooth and runs badly enough to send you chasing ignition and carburation faults for weeks. Any LA of unknown history should have its timing set renewed as preventive maintenance; the parts are cheap and the job is a known quantity, roughly $400–800 fitted with a quality double-roller set. Valve stem seals harden with age and heat, so a puff of blue smoke on start-up after standing, clearing within seconds, is normal behaviour on an old LA rather than a death sentence; continuous smoke under load points instead to rings or bores. The exhaust manifold bolts, particularly at the rear of the right-hand manifold, seize and snap; budget for drilling and extraction if an exhaust blow is present, typically $250–600 depending on access. Oil leaks come from the rocker cover gaskets, the rear main seal and the intake manifold end seals, in roughly that order of frequency, and none is expensive in parts — the cost is labour and access. The cooling system is conventional and generously sized, but the youngest M-body car is now well over three decades old, so radiators, heater cores and hoses are age items, not mileage items.

Carburation, Lean Burn and electronic spark control

If an LA-engined Fifth Avenue runs badly, the smart money checks the engine management before the carburettor, because these cars span the most awkward decade of American emissions control. Early cars use Chrysler's Electronic Lean Burn system, later renamed Electronic Spark Control: a computer, mounted conspicuously on the side of the air cleaner housing, that controls ignition timing and, on feedback cars, carburettor mixture, using inputs from sensors around the engine. The concept was advanced for its day. The execution, four decades on, is the single largest source of drivability complaints on these cars: the computers fail with heat and age, the vacuum and temperature sensors drift or die, connectors corrode, and the symptoms — stumbling, surging, stalling at junctions, a flat spot on light throttle, hard starting hot or cold — mimic carburettor faults so convincingly that generations of owners have rebuilt carburettors that were never the problem.

Learn the distinguishing tests. The carburettor itself — Carter two-barrel on the early cars, Rochester Quadrajet on the four-barrel M-body — is a conventional instrument that a competent carburettor shop can rebuild for roughly $300–600, and a genuinely faulty one usually shows its hand with flooding, a visibly worn throttle shaft, a dead accelerator pump (test it: look down the throat while a helper snaps the throttle and watch for two strong jets of fuel) or a choke that does not pull off as the engine warms. If the fuelling checks out and the car still stumbles and surges, test the spark side: an intermittent Lean Burn computer characteristically produces faults that come and go with underbonnet temperature, worsening as the engine bay heat-soaks. Many cars have already been converted by previous owners to a conventional electronic ignition — the later Chrysler electronic distributor with a separate ignition module, the well-known orange-box conversion — and a tidy conversion, properly wired, is a positive on a car you intend to drive, not a demerit. What you want to avoid is a half-finished conversion: cut looms, a ballast resistor bypassed with twisted wire, vacuum advance connected to the wrong port. The inspection checklist gives you the underbonnet look that separates the two.

The Quadrajet deserves a specific word, because it attracts a specific myth. You will be told the four-barrel cars are troublesome because the carburettor is a GM design on a Chrysler engine. The carburettor does not know what engine it sits on; it meters fuel against airflow like any other, and its known needs are those of any Quadrajet — float level correct, secondary air valve tension correct, throttle shafts not worn oval in the body. A Quadrajet that bogs on acceleration is almost always an adjustment or wear issue, diagnosable on the car, not a reason to reject the model year.

The Y-body V6s: 3.3 and 3.8

The front-drive Fifth Avenue replaces the LA with Chrysler's own V6 family, mounted transversely and driving the front wheels. The 3.3-litre engine of the 1990 cars and the 3.8-litre fitted from 1991 are pushrod, overhead-valve designs with a single camshaft in the block, sequential electronic fuel injection and distributorless ignition — no carburettor, no Lean Burn computer, and a completely different fault pattern from the V8 cars. Outputs are around 147 hp for the 3.3 and 150 hp for the 3.8, figures that flatter neither engine's real character: both make their useful torque low down, the 3.8 noticeably more so, and the bigger engine is the one to buy because the Y-body is a heavy car and the 3.3 has to work for its living.

These are durable engines with a long service life in minivans and sedans alike, and their problems are those of age and neglect rather than design. The serpentine belt and its tensioner are service items; a chirping belt on a cold start that fades as things warm up is the tensioner announcing itself, and a belt-and-tensioner job runs roughly $150–300. Coolant leaks appear at the water pump and the intake manifold gaskets. The rocker cover gaskets weep oil onto the exhaust manifolds and produce the hot-oil smell sellers will blame on anything else. None of this is serious. What is serious on a Y-body is not in this section: it is the gearbox the engine is bolted to, covered next, because it should shape your whole approach to the generation.

Gearboxes: TorqueFlite and Ultradrive

The rear-drive cars use the TorqueFlite, Chrysler's three-speed automatic, in its smaller 904-series form behind the 318. The TorqueFlite's reputation is earned: it is one of the most durable automatic gearboxes ever fitted to an American car, it tolerates neglect that would kill a modern unit, and any competent transmission shop in North America knows it intimately. It has no electronics, and one adjustment that matters enormously. The throttle-pressure linkage — the rod running from the carburettor linkage down to the lever on the gearbox — controls line pressure and shift timing in proportion to throttle opening. If it is disconnected, misadjusted or seized, the gearbox shifts early and soft at exactly the moments it should shift firm, the clutches slip, and a healthy gearbox can be destroyed in a few hundred miles. Sellers rarely know this; a car that flares between shifts or shifts suspiciously early under load may have a linkage problem costing tens of dollars to correct, or a gearbox already damaged by it costing $1,500–2,500 to rebuild. The test is in the inspection section, and it is one of the most valuable checks in this guide. A TorqueFlite that shifts cleanly, engages drive and reverse without delay or a thump, and shows clean red fluid on its dipstick is, in practice, a solved problem — budget for fluid and filter services, not for failure.

The Y-body's Ultradrive A604 four-speed is the opposite ownership experience, and you should go in with your eyes open. It is an electronically controlled gearbox, managed by its own transmission computer, and in period it earned a genuinely poor reputation for early failures — harsh or erratic shifting, slipping, and a limp-home mode that locks the gearbox in second gear when the computer detects a fault. Four decades of hindsight soften the verdict in one important way: a large share of Ultradrive trouble traces to two correctable causes. The first is fluid. The A604 is specified for Chrysler's own ATF+ fluid (ATF+3, later ATF+4), and period failures multiplied when shops filled them with generic Dexron-type fluid, whose friction characteristics the clutch packs and control strategy are not calibrated for; a Y-body with a documented history of correct fluid is a materially better bet than one without. The second is electronics rather than internals: the solenoid pack on the outside of the case, the input and output speed sensors, and corroded connectors account for many of the shift faults and limp-mode episodes laid at the gearbox's door, and those are repairs in the $200–600 range rather than a $2,000–3,000 rebuild. But a genuinely worn A604 is a genuinely expensive gearbox, parts and knowledge for it are thinner than for the TorqueFlite, and the inspection section's cold-drive test matters more on this generation than on any other part of the car. Price a Y-body as if the gearbox will need money until the car proves otherwise.

A black 1987 car in profile, and the profile is the lesson: formal upright C-pillar under the padded roof, long rear overhang, chrome wheel-arch trims and whitewall tyres on wire covers. On any M-body, sight down this flank for ripples — these are big, flat panels that show accident repair mercilessly, and they rust from the bottom edge up.

Problem areas

Rust and structure: the map

A Fifth Avenue rarely dies of its engine. It dies of rust, of the cost of the rust, or of the vinyl roof that hid the rust until the cost became absurd. Work to a map, and work underneath the car, because the shiny parts of a Fifth Avenue lie fluently.

Start with the structure that carries the front suspension, because the M-body's layout creates its signature failure. The front wheels are suspended on transverse torsion bars, and those bars anchor into a front crossmember assembly. The anchor areas and the crossmember itself trap road dirt and moisture, and they rot — a car can present clean sills and shiny paint while the metal around the torsion bar anchors is perforated and weak, which is a structural failure on the part that keeps the front suspension attached to the car. Get the car on a lift, or get yourself on the ground with a torch and a screwdriver, and probe the crossmember around the anchor points and along its seams. Surface scale is normal; flaking, holes and metal that dents under firm screwdriver pressure are a walk-away on a car at ordinary money, because proper repair means fabrication and welding in a structural area, typically $1,000–2,500 a side once access, alignment and refinishing are counted.

Work backwards from there. The floor pans rust from the inside out wherever the carpets have stayed wet — lift the mats, front and rear, and press the floor with your palm; a floor that feels spongy or sounds dull and crunchy is holed or about to be. The boot floor rusts around the spare wheel well and along its seams, fed by leaking bootlid seals and by the tail lamp gaskets. The rear leaf spring hangers and the frame rails around them are a known M-body rot point, and they matter structurally: a spring hanger pulling away from a rotten rail is not a cosmetic fault. Wheel arches rust at the lip where the trim traps mud, door bottoms rust along the lower seam, and the lower front wings rust behind the wheel where road spray is thrown. Sills on these cars are less notorious than the crossmember, but check the jacking points by the test in the inspection section.

Then the roof, which is this model's special trap. The Fifth Avenue's padded vinyl roof covering is glued over the steel roof and the formal rear side panels, and vinyl that looks merely tired — cracked, split at the seams, lifting at the edges — is admitting water to the steel beneath, where it sits against the padding and rusts the roof and the C-pillar area invisibly. Bubbling in the vinyl, staining at the headlining edges and a musty interior are the visible symptoms of an invisible problem. Peeling back damaged vinyl to find sound metal is a good day; finding perforated roof steel means cutting, welding and a new covering, a job that runs $1,500–3,500 done properly and writes off a cheap car. A car with an intact, supple, well-sealed original roof covering is worth a premium over a car with a shiny repaint and cracked vinyl, and this guide's which-one-to-buy section says so again, because buyers consistently price it the wrong way round.

On the Y-body, the structural watch item is different: the front engine cradle (the subframe that carries the engine, gearbox and front suspension) corrodes, particularly on cars from salt states, and perforation there is a safety and cost problem of the same order as the M-body's crossmember. The same torch-and-screwdriver discipline applies, along with the floor, sill and arch checks common to any unit-body car of the period.

Engine and drivability

The LA V8's mechanical core is the least of your worries; its ancillaries and management are where the money and the misery live. Beyond the timing chain, valve seals and manifold bolts covered in the engines section, budget attention for the following. The choke system — electric choke heater, choke pull-off diaphragm and the fast-idle linkage — is the usual cause of the classic complaint pair: hard starting cold and stalling in the first mile, or a racing idle that never settles. Each component is testable in minutes and cheap in isolation; the expensive version of this fault is the owner who replaces the carburettor first. The heat riser valve in the exhaust manifold, which routes exhaust heat to the intake during warm-up, seizes with age: seized shut it cooks the intake charge and causes hot-running and detonation; seized open it slows warm-up and worsens cold stumble. It should move freely against its spring and counterweight when you flick it by hand on a cold engine. Fuel pumps and their eccentric drive are conventional and cheap. The electronic ignition itself, where the original Lean Burn has been retained, fails as described in the engines section — heat-related, intermittent, and misdiagnosed as fuel. Where it has been converted, judge the conversion's workmanship, not its existence.

Oil consumption deserves a calm head. An LA that uses a quart of oil between changes, smokes briefly on start-up and shows clean plugs is an old engine behaving normally, and sellers who describe it as rebuilt should be asked for the invoice. An LA that smokes under acceleration, fouls one plug repeatedly or blows blue smoke on the overrun after a long descent has a specific fault — rings, a guide, one cylinder's problem — and a compression test followed by a leak-down test on the suspect cylinder will name it before you buy, which is the only order in which to do these things. Overheating complaints are almost never the engine: they are a silted radiator, a collapsed lower hose sucking flat under pump suction (squeeze it; the internal spring should keep it round), a failed viscous fan coupling (spin the fan on a hot, stopped engine — it should resist, not freewheel), or a thermostat fitted backwards by an optimist. All four are cheap. A car presented with the thermostat removed entirely has an overheating fault the seller could not find, and you should price it as such.

The Y-body V6s invert the pattern: the engines are the calm part and the electronics around them do the complaining. Idle faults and stalling usually trace to the idle air control motor and a carboned throttle body, cleaned or renewed for modest money. Crankshaft and camshaft position sensor failures cause the classic dies-when-hot, restarts-when-cool pattern and are inexpensive parts whose diagnosis, not cost, is the hurdle. But do not accept a seller attributing every Y-body fault to a sensor: on this generation the gearbox imitates engine faults — a shuddering Ultradrive at light throttle feels exactly like a misfire until you learn to tell them apart by whether the shudder follows road speed and gear rather than engine load.

Gearbox and driveline

For the TorqueFlite cars, the driveline section of your inspection is short and mostly reassuring, provided you run the two checks that matter. The first is the throttle-pressure linkage, described in the engines and gearboxes section: find it, confirm it is connected at both ends, confirm it moves through its full travel when a helper works the throttle, and confirm it is not seized with corrosion or bent from a past engine removal. A disconnected linkage is the single most expensive ten-dollar fault on the whole car. The second is the fluid: on a TorqueFlite the dipstick tells the truth. Fluid should be red and translucent; brown, dark or burnt-smelling fluid means a gearbox that has been hot, and a gearbox that has been hot has been slipping. Shift quality should be unremarkable — a TorqueFlite in health is neither silky nor harsh, it simply changes gear at sensible points with a mild firmness. Flaring (revs rising during a change), delayed engagement of drive or reverse from cold, and a whine that follows road speed are the faults that justify either a specialist's pre-purchase opinion or a price that assumes a rebuild at $1,500–2,500. Behind the gearbox, the live axle is a simple, strong unit: check for a pinion seal leak (oil flung in a line along the floor above the axle nose), listen for a bearing growl that rises with road speed, and accept the slight clunk on taking up drive that worn universal joints produce — joints are a $150–350 job, not a negotiation centrepiece. Rear leaf springs sag with age and miles, and a car sitting visibly low at the rear with its springs flattened or an inverted arch needs a spring budget of roughly $400–800 the pair fitted; check the hangers for the rust described above while you are looking.

For the Ultradrive, the driveline is the inspection. The fault catalogue is specific. Limp-home mode — the gearbox holding second gear and refusing to change — means the transmission computer has logged a fault it considers serious; it may be a speed sensor at $50–150 in parts, a solenoid pack at a few hundred, or the beginning of internal failure, and you cannot tell which from the driver's seat, so a car presented in limp mode is priced as a gearbox rebuild until a code read proves otherwise. Harsh engagement of drive, shuddering on light-throttle upshifts, and a bump on the downshift to a stop are the wear symptoms; some harshness can be improved by the correct fluid and a relearn procedure, and a seller who tells you a fluid change will certainly cure shuddering is selling you the hope, not the car. Ask for the fluid history in writing if it exists. A Y-body whose gearbox is quiet, clean-shifting and documented on ATF+ fluid is a genuinely usable modern classic; a Y-body with an undocumented, symptomatic Ultradrive is the one car in this guide where the standard advice inverts — walk away even if the body is beautiful, because the body is not the expensive part of this generation.

Suspension, steering and brakes

The M-body's front suspension is the Aspen/Volare design: transverse torsion bars, upper and lower control arms, and a steering box with a linkage that includes an idler arm — and the idler arm is the wear item that defines how these cars feel. A worn idler arm and tired tie-rod ends give the classic symptoms: a dead zone at the straight-ahead, wander on a crowned road, and a car that needs constant small corrections on the motorway. None of it is expensive — idler arms, tie-rod ends and ball joints are all ordinary parts, and a full front-end refresh with alignment runs roughly $600–1,200 — but it transforms the car, and a seller's claim that they all wander like that is a claim about neglected ones. Ball joints are checked the standard way, with the car lifted and the wheel levered top and bottom; torsion bars themselves rarely fail but their anchor area is the rust point already covered. Power steering pumps whine when low or worn, and the high-pressure hose weeps at its crimps; both are modest jobs. The steering box itself can be adjusted for some play, and a box adjusted to the end of its travel to hide wear will feel tight at the centre and bind on lock — turn the wheel lock to lock on the test drive and feel for it.

Brakes are front discs and rear drums, vacuum-boosted, and entirely conventional. The age faults are seized rear wheel cylinders (one rear wheel locking early, or a handbrake that holds on one side only), perished flexible hoses, a master cylinder that lets the pedal sink slowly at a standstill, and front calipers with sticking pistons producing a pull under braking. Parts are cheap and everywhere; a full brake overhaul with hoses, cylinders, pads, shoes and fluid is a $500–900 job at a general shop, and you should simply assume a neglected car needs it.

The Y-body substitutes struts for the torsion bars, and its wear pattern is the modern one: strut top mounts that knock over low-speed bumps, front wheel bearings that hum and change note as you load them in gentle bends, and CV joints that click on full lock when their boots have split. All are diagnosable on a ten-minute drive and none is a reason to reject a car priced accordingly.

Electrics, interior and trim

Electrics on the rear-drive cars are simple in architecture and tired in execution. The charging system uses a conventional alternator with an electronic regulator; low charge at idle with the lights and blower on points to a tired alternator or, as often, corroded connections at the bulkhead connector, a known Chrysler weak point where high-current wiring passes through the firewall. Clean, tight terminals cure faults that get quoted as alternators and starters. Fusible links — short lengths of sacrificial wire in the main feeds — fail with age and produce total, baffling electrical death that is actually a ten-dollar part. Power windows are slow when healthy and slower when the motors and regulators are dry and worn; a window that needs helping by hand needs a motor or regulator, roughly $150–350 a door fitted. The power seat mechanisms, the opera lamps in the C-pillars and the other period luxuries fail one at a time and are fixed one at a time; none should decide a purchase, but a car with everything working is a car that has been maintained, and that correlation is worth money.

The Y-body adds electronic instruments, more body electronics and automatic climate control to the list, and its faults are correspondingly more electronic: instrument clusters with failing solder joints and intermittent gauges, climate control heads that lose their displays, and blend-door actuators that click and fail to move the air where you ask for it. Diagnosis needs the factory procedures and patience; parts supply is thinner than for the M-body, and this is the generation where a specialist's pre-purchase scan earns its fee.

Interiors decide values on Fifth Avenues more than on most cars, because the interior is the product. The M-body's loose-pillow seats came in velour or leather, and both age in specific ways. Velour wears shiny on the driver's bolster and fades unevenly where the sun reaches it, and it cannot be patched invisibly; a worn velour interior is a retrim decision, and a full retrim in correct-style material is a $2,500–5,000 commitment that should be in the price, not discovered after it. Leather dries, cracks on the seat faces and splits at the seams; feeding and dyeing improve a dry interior dramatically, but split seams mean a trimmer. Headlinings sag on all three generations — the foam backing disintegrates and the cloth drops — and the correct fix is the board out and new material on, at $300–600; the incorrect fix, pins and spray glue, is visible from the driver's seat and tells you about the previous owner's standards. Dash pads crack in the sun. Carpets fade and, worse, hold the water that rots the floors, so a wet-smelling car is a rust suspect until the floors are proven.

Trim is the quiet budget-eater. The bright wheel-arch mouldings, the rocker trims, the grille, the tail lamp lenses with their segmented Fifth Avenue pattern, the wire wheel covers and the roof ornamentation are model-specific, largely unreproduced, and priced by scarcity when they surface. A car missing its brightwork or wearing dented, peeling trim is not a weekend's detailing away from right; it is a parts hunt. Conversely, complete, straight, bright trim on an otherwise ordinary car is real value. Check the wire wheel covers individually: they are heavy, they work loose, they get kerbed, and a matching set of four good ones is harder to assemble than you expect.

A 1984 car from the side, and what to study is the lower half of the picture: sill line, door bottoms, wheel-arch lips and the bright rocker trim, all straight and all sitting at the right height on a car whose rear springs have not sagged. Compare the car you are inspecting against this stance — a Fifth Avenue sitting nose-high is telling you about its rear springs and spring hangers before you even get underneath.

How to inspect one

Work in this order. It is arranged so the faults that kill the deal come first, while you are still fresh and the seller is still patient, and so each step uses what the earlier steps found. Allow an hour, insist on a cold engine, and bring a torch, a screwdriver, a magnet in a cloth, and a helper.

  1. Paperwork and identity first. Read the VIN plate through the windscreen and match it to the title. Confirm the car is the generation the advert claims — R-body New Yorker edition, M-body rear-drive car or Y-body front-drive car — using the models section. A misdescribed generation ends the inspection here, politely.
  2. Cold start, standing outside. Have the seller start the car from stone cold while you stand at the rear. A brief puff of blue smoke that clears is valve seals and is normal for an LA; sustained smoke is not. Listen for a rattle in the first seconds (timing chain slack and tired lifters both announce themselves cold) and for exhaust blows at the manifolds.
  3. The roof, before anything else cosmetic. Walk the vinyl roof slowly. Press gently along the seams and around the rear side panels: crunchiness or movement under the vinyl means rust beneath it, the trap from the rust section. Check the headlining edges inside for water staining. A failed roof reprices the whole car.
  4. The structural probe. Under the car with torch and screwdriver: on an M-body, the front crossmember around the torsion bar anchors; on an R-body, the front subframe; on a Y-body, the engine cradle. Then the rear spring hangers and rails, the floor edges and the boot floor. Firm probing, not stabbing — you are testing whether the metal is structure or scale.
  5. Floors from inside. Lift the mats front and rear, press the floor pans hard with your palm, and smell the carpets. Wet carpet plus a dull, crunchy floor is the inside-out rust described in the problem areas, and it means the outer shine is irrelevant.
  6. The sill and jacking test. With the car's own jack on each sill jacking point in turn, lift just enough to load it and watch and listen: a sill or floor edge that flexes, cracks its paint or crunches is rotten where it matters. This settles the sills the way the probe settles the crossmember.
  7. Under the bonnet: management before machinery. On an LA car, identify what is controlling the spark: original Lean Burn or Electronic Spark Control computer on the air cleaner, or a conversion. Judge a conversion by its wiring quality. Check the throttle-pressure linkage to the gearbox — connected, free through its travel — because the gearbox section explains what a disconnected one costs. Flick the heat riser; it should move against its spring.
  8. Fluids, all of them. Engine oil for mayonnaise under the filler cap and for level; coolant for rust and oil; brake fluid for darkness; and on the automatic, the dipstick test from the driveline section — red and sweet-smelling is health, brown and burnt is a negotiation or a goodbye. On a Y-body, ask directly what fluid the gearbox has been run on and listen carefully to the answer.
  9. The cold drive: gearbox first. Drive away gently and note engagement of drive and reverse before the car warms up — delay or a thump is data. On a TorqueFlite car, feel for flare between changes and for suspiciously early, soft shifts under load, the linkage signature. On an Ultradrive car, any limp-mode behaviour, shudder or harsh change ends the mechanical inspection: the car is priced as a gearbox job until a code read says otherwise.
  10. The warm drive: steering, brakes, bearings. At motorway speed, feel for the straight-ahead dead zone and wander of a worn idler arm; brake firmly from speed for pull and pedal sink; listen in gentle bends for wheel bearing hum on a Y-body and for axle growl on a rear-drive car; turn lock to lock in a car park for steering box bind and, on the Y-body, CV joint clicking.
  11. Everything electrical, one switch at a time. Windows up and down, seat motors, blower on every speed, air conditioning if fitted (cold air at the vents on a warm day is a system that works; a seller's assurance is not), opera lamps, lights, wipers and washers. On a Y-body, cycle the climate control through its modes and watch the instrument cluster for dropouts.
  12. The trim audit, last because it is the easiest to forgive wrongly. Walk the car for the brightwork inventory from the electrics and trim section: grille, arch mouldings, rocker trims, tail lamp lenses, all four wire wheel covers, roof ornamentation. Price every missing or damaged piece as a parts hunt, not as a detail, and add the total to your mental cost of the car before you make an offer.

Values

The Values section of this guide deliberately contains no prices, because the market content computed from this site's own listings and recorded sales sits directly beneath the guide and is refreshed as the market moves; anything printed here would be stale before it was read twice. What does not go stale is how to read that market, and the Fifth Avenue market has a particular shape you need to understand before the numbers mean anything.

The first feature of the shape is the spread. Few models show a wider gap between the cheapest and the dearest examples relative to what the cars are, because the Fifth Avenue is bought on condition almost to the exclusion of everything else. The mechanical package is durable and cheap to fix, so mechanical state moves prices less than you expect; what moves them is the body, the roof and the interior — the three things that are expensive to put right. A mechanically tired car with a sound shell, a sealed roof and a good interior is the bargain of the range. A shiny car with a crunchy roof and a tired cabin is the trap, and it is usually priced as if the shine were the substance. Read every asking price as a claim about those three things and check the claim in that order.

The second feature is the generation split. The M-body car is the market: it is what most buyers want, what most sellers have, and where the recorded sales cluster thickly enough to read a trend. Within it, the four-barrel cars from 1985 onward carry a modest premium for being the better drive, and genuinely low-mileage, original, well-documented cars carry a larger one, because the supply of Fifth Avenues that have never been neglected is small and shrinking — most led ordinary lives as ordinary transport and were used accordingly. The R-body car trades in a thinner market where individual condition and the patience of the one buyer who wants a full-size R-body matter more than any guide figure; expect negotiation to be a conversation, not a percentage. The Y-body is the cheapest way into the name and will stay that way while its gearbox reputation hangs over it; the recorded sales reflect the fear as much as the cars, and a documented, correctly maintained Y-body bought at the fearful price is the contrarian opportunity of the range.

Third, understand the project-versus-driver gap, because it is wider here than the cars' simplicity suggests. A project Fifth Avenue looks cheap because the parts are cheap, and that logic holds for the mechanical work — brakes, front-end wear, carburation and ignition are all modest money. It collapses at the body shop. Structural welding, roof replacement and a retrim each cost what they cost on any car, and two of the three together exceed the value of the finished car at any realistic market level. The rational project needs one expensive thing; the irrational one, however cheap, needs two. Sellers of projects rarely price that distinction in; buyers should.

Finally, negotiation reality.

Parts and ownership

Ownership of a rear-drive Fifth Avenue is one of the easiest classic-car propositions in America, and the reason is the relatives. The M-body platform was built in volume for a decade, its Diplomat and Gran Fury siblings filled police and taxi fleets, and the LA V8 was Chrysler's standard small-block across cars and trucks for a generation. Mechanical parts — engine internals, gaskets, pumps, alternators, starters, brake components, suspension wear items, carburettor kits, ignition parts — are available from any competent parts counter, usually off the shelf, and the aftermarket for the LA engine is enormous because the same architecture powers half the classic Mopar world. A TorqueFlite needs no specialist network; it needs any transmission shop that has been in business for more than a decade. Routine servicing is within the ability of a home mechanic with a factory service manual — buy the manual for your year before you buy your first part, because the wiring diagrams and the Lean Burn test procedures alone repay it.

The scarcity is in the model-specific layer, and you should plan around it rather than discover it. Fifth Avenue trim, brightwork, tail lamp lenses, roof coverings and interior materials in the correct patterns are not reproduced in any depth. The supply is new-old-stock, the stock of the Mopar parts specialists, and salvage — and salvage supply is thinning, because these cars were worth little for long enough that yards crushed them without stripping the trim. The ownership habit this creates is simple: when you find good trim, lenses or interior pieces for your car at a fair price, buy them, even if you do not need them yet. Owners of these cars keep a shelf. It is not hoarding; it is the difference between a weekend fix and a six-month hunt in five years' time.

The R-body car sits at the difficult end of the same spectrum: its mechanical parts are shared LA and TorqueFlite fare, but body, trim and interior pieces are specific to a short-lived, low-volume flagship and are genuinely hard. Buy an R-body on the completeness of the car in front of you, not on the promise of finding what is missing. The Y-body splits the difference — its V6 and its service parts are common with the minivan and sedan ranges and easy, its gearbox expertise and some of its electronics and trim are the thin layer, and a Y-body owner benefits from finding the transmission shop that knows the Ultradrive before they need it.

Running one is otherwise undemanding. Fuel consumption is what a large, softly tuned American sedan of the period gives you, and no honest guide will dress it up; you buy this car for torque, quiet and comfort, not economy. Insurance and registration sit in the ordinary classic brackets. The cars are simple enough to store well — the enemies in storage are the roof covering drying and splitting, the fuel system varnishing, and mice in the velour — and they reward regular use more than most classics, because the seals, the carburettor and the air conditioning all stay healthier exercised than rested.

Which one to buy

The overriding rule: buy the body, the roof and the interior, and let the mechanicals follow — on a Fifth Avenue the LA V8 and the TorqueFlite can almost always be put right for ordinary money, but rust under the vinyl, rot in the crossmember and a worn-out cabin cost more than the car will ever be worth, so the best Fifth Avenue is the most honest shell with the best trim, not the shiniest paint or the lowest odometer.

See the 1 Fifth Avenue cars currently listed.

What they sell for: Fifth Avenue sale prices.

Related guides

Chrysler Full Size buyer's guideChrysler Imperial buyer's guideChrysler New Yorker buyer's guideChrysler Newport buyer's guideChrysler Royal Factory Original buyer's guideChrysler Town And Country buyer's guideChrysler Windsor buyer's guide